Oh absolutely man, everything Reddit was/is lemmy is currently (imo) doing better. I might end up back on Reddit from googling some niche questions, but I’m actually engaging on lemmy whereas on Reddit I lurked since there was no purpose to even try and contribute

I was user of the official Reddit app. Started using Apollo at the start of June after it was announced to be shutting down. I guess I wanted to see if I had been missing anything.

Totally fell in love with it and am kicking myself for not switching sooner. And now that it is gone, I can’t ignore all the flaws of the official app. Not to mention the entire vibe is off now.

I’m still using Reddit, but wayyy less since I had to switch back to the Reddit App. So I found my way to KBin.

I’m really loving the vibe of the fediverse. It’s a little harder to find communities, and the niche ones aren’t as populated. But it is just so optimistic and free feeling. I want to hang here and see it grow, and I really hope it takes off in a big way.

Btw I can firmly be described as a casual Reddit user. I mostly lurked, posted a comment every now and then… I feel like my experience is not unique.

Really interested to see the traffic numbers after the API rollout, cause if my experience isn’t unique (and again, I am a normie) then I think it is going very bad for Reddit right now.

If anything, they’ll blame it on the launch of Threads and not their own bad decisions.

Plus don’t forget the effect of bots, especially those created specifically to mess with the protests. I saw people going around to subs they had NEVER visited before in their entire existence, and spreading misinformation and generalized disorder. Often they were quite upfront about their purpose even.

Like, polls should be for those who participate in THAT community, not some rando from somewhere else on the internet entirely? I’m not trying to spread a conspiracy theory, but I will say that if I were part of a Russian troll farm, I would 100% have done that, in order to keep people on Reddit where my disinformation content could more easily reach them. (Thus it’s hard to imagine them NOT doing that… maybe, plus many others doing the same just for the fun of it and enjoying helping spread the chaos.)

@FizzlePopBerryTwist:
It might be good to ignore all accounts created since the week prior to the protests and moving forward, since there likely would not have been so many accounts created organically, but it would be expected to be enriched in trolling accounts, even if not bots.

You’re right to compare it to the other sites. It looks like people are dropping social media in general, and a lot of reddit’s losses could be caused by that instead of the admins pissing people off.

That said, I think all of those losses are pretty huge, considering it’s only a month. Extrapolate those numbers to a year and they become more like 10-30% depending on the site, which is pretty devastating.

If those are steady losses, some of those platforms may not exist in 5 years. I think that’s a crazy thought.

But yeah, I agree with you, Reddit didn’t lose that much more than the other sites, so I don’t think this shows a giant exodus just because of because of the api changes.

Depends how much quality content that group contributed.

aww yeahhhh

Especially with BotDefense having given up the fight.

@FizzlePopBerryTwist
Time that users spend on the site might be a better metric?

Hmmm, good point.

Probably get more people once a better client is established, using liftoff or connect just depending cause they definitely both have flaws.

It’s over for reddit, they just don’t know it yet.

It’s less that they don’t know, and more that they don’t care. IPOs are about unloading your bags onto someone else.

They’ve consciously decided that the value of the content they’ve already captured is worth more than the value that future content will bring them. Now they just have to get out from under the pyramid before it collapses.

I think a lot of people are thinking that social media dies when nobody uses it. I think those people also don’t realize that Digg still exists.

Reddit will slowly slump into the endless morass of meaningless social media that’s largely irrelevant, having lost anything that ever made it actually special.