Link to the modlog: https://reddthat.com/modlog/11298

Link to the community: [email protected]

Edit: for context, I first sent a DM to the single mod asking them if we could consider merging communities (basically my comment below). They ignored me but opened the thread.

My comment

Should we maybe consider merging this one with [email protected] ? We have regular pinned posts and movie-specific discussion threads over there, and that community has been more active than this one lately, be it weekly or monthly (1.54k vs 1.32k and 2.92k vs 2.51k). The moderation team has several people, including movie enthusiasts who post there regularly. We had our first AMA a while ago a few weeks ago: https://lemm.ee/post/31335226 And if people ask why we wanted to have a community on another instance than Lemmy.world, the large majority of active communities are already on LW (https://lemmyverse.net/communities?order=active), it seems better to spread communities a bit.

Reason for removal

Not currently considering this action Maybe in the future.

I guess I’m just a bit sad that they removed the comment altogether instead of letting it there and considering a discussion.

I’ve heard several times that Lemmy should consolidate communities (like what happened with [email protected] and [email protected] recently), but I guess it’s easier said than done.

In the meantime, congrats for making this community the most active one!

  • Blaze@reddthat.comOPEnglish
    27·
    6 months ago

    I wanted to stop there but if you want to give it another go, sure.

    First of all, there has been “self promotion” about this community on [email protected] in the past:

    I had a few discussions via DM with the main mod in the past, all went well as you can see above.

    Also, he didn’t add the reason of his removal as “self promotion”, but as “Not currently considering this action”. He didn’t even mention breaking any rule.

    putting them on blast so publicly

    I would have rather preferred having discussed that over DMs, but he never replied to my first.

    Also, aren’t modlogs public for a reason, to keep moderators accountable for their decisions?

    • smoothbrain coldtakes@lemmy.caEnglish
      8·
      6 months ago

      Your effort to conglomerate all communities under your banner is basically the antithesis of the federated model, and even if it was not considered self promotion, I can see clearly why it was considered overtly hostile and removed.

      For somebody who cares deeply about the federation, its userbase, statistics and otherwise, you are actually replicating one of the major issues with reddit that federation was trying to solve. Stop trying to be a powermod in the name of defragmentation. It’s just centralization of power.