European Commission - Have your say
ec.europa.eu
European Commission - Have your say

You may want to comment on the European Union’s approach to digital funding, ‘chat control’, taxing multinationals, research and innovation, and more.

Tell EU politicians your opinion and offer aspects they are unlikely to hear from corporate executives and lobbyists.

  • activistPnk@slrpnk.netEnglish
    21·
    4 months ago

    That’s the same portal that they expected us to use to report what a shit show GDPR enforcement has been the past 4 years. The irony was the site demanded more information than necessary – thus the site asking how is the GDPR going was itself infringing on data minimisation. It’s fussy about who hosts the email address they force you to disclose. I eventually got an account after revealing more than I wanted to and then the JavaScript doc submission app gave vague errors anyway and could not be used. It also forces periodic password changes which seems a bit over the top for this sort of mission.

    tl;dr: not everyone can have their say. Only some people.

    • Oneser@lemm.eeEnglish
      4·
      4 months ago

      I get the joke, but we use this forum at work frequently, it has some sway during the consultation phase of discussion.

      • mathemachristian[he]@lemm.eeEnglish
        12·
        4 months ago

        I have never seen important policy being decided by what the populace thinks. Like ever. If anything people have to protest loudly and organise to raise hell and even then it will silently be swept aside a month or two later.

        Remember the huge anti-nazi demonstrations across the republic that even olaf scholz appeared at? Whatever happened because of that? Or fridays for future? The only change there has been that it is trendy to be ecofriendly now and so corporations try to put on a facade to sell their stuff but we are not going to meet our “goals” and meanwhile china is about to meet the climate goals they have set for 2030. The last time the population was consulted was to get the opinion on daylight savings and even then the project was scrapped.

        Feel free to change my mind but it’s going to be tough.

        Edit: this actually got me going, the fact that it has “some sway” during the consultation phase shows how bankrupt the whole system really is, because the industrialists and lobbyists get a seat at the table but the best we can hope for is to leave some comments on the internet that might be taken into consideration?

        • Oneser@lemm.eeEnglish
          2·
          4 months ago

          Hmmm while I get your point, I was only saying that I have seen cases where the comments of proposals were seen by the commission, discussed further and then actioned upon. The most recent example that comes to my mind was the delay of the cybersecurity requirements within the radio equipment directive.

          I did not say that public action is adequately taken into account and I am not privvy to what the direct intentions or submissions (on a legislative level) are for Fridays for Future etc.

          I would however give credit where due to the EU for trying to actually force companies selling here to act in an eco friendly manner (e.g USB-C amendments, charger requirements, eco design regulation, carbon based price schemes). More is needed, but it’s better than many other democracies