In-display fingerprint sensors have become commonplace in virtually all Android smartphones, for better or for worse, and five years later...

In-display fingerprint sensors have become commonplace in virtually all Android smartphones, for better or for worse, and five years later…

  • Buffalox@lemmy.worldEnglish
    101·
    20 days ago

    Are ultrasonic sensors better apart from the light hing? That I have never even thought about could be a problem.
    Mine detects b between up to 5 fingers, and it’s fast and with good accuracy, which is nice because depending on the situation I may use either hand.

    • Virkkunen@fedia.io
      71·
      20 days ago

      They are way better, faster without sacrificing precision/security. With an ultrasonic sensor I can simply tap the screen and it’s unlocked, where with the optical ones I’d need to press for a second before unlocking, sometimes having to shuffle my finger around.

      • disconnectikacio@lemmy.worldEnglish
        4·
        20 days ago

        I experienced the complete opposite. Ultrasonic was crap, inaccurate, and slow (until it stopped working completely), while optical was just a tap, and very accurate

        • darkstar@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
          12·
          19 days ago

          You probably used some cheap crappy chinese knock off ultrasonic then, because they do work, and much much better than optical

          • disconnectikacio@lemmy.worldEnglish
            31·
            19 days ago

            Yeah, a “cheap” top tier huawei p30 pro that cost about 600$ when it was new 😆

            I dont think ultrasonic can be better, but regardless of sensor tech, in screen sensor is absolutely crap, i put the inventors to the same box as the inventors/pushers of micro usb, curved edge phone screens, removing jack connectors, etc… these things arey very annoying, and very useless.

          • BlueFire@lemdro.idEnglish
            2·
            18 days ago

            I have the P9p and have more issues with the (ultra sonic) sensor than I did with the (optical sensor) on the previous P8p.

            I even compared both in hand before trading in the older phone and the P8p scanning was much better.

            Though I have to mention; to improve the optical sensor reading I had to do 4 fingerprints with different brightness for each scan, and that what helped a lot.

            Too bad I can’t do the same with the Ultrasonic sensor since it doesn’t care about the brightness on the screen.

    • Byter@lemmy.oneEnglish
      3·
      20 days ago

      I went Galaxy S22 Ultra (ultrasonic) to Pixel 8 Pro (optical) to Pixel 9 XL (ultrasonic).

      My impression was the performance improved over time with the Galaxy and Pixel 8. I find the Pixel 9 worst overall, but figure they’ll improve it in software.

      No data to back that up.

      It mostly struggles when my hand is wet. I miss the Pixel 4’s face unlock.

      • BlueFire@lemdro.idEnglish
        1·
        18 days ago

        Pixel 9 pro struggles with my finger scan if it’s too dry. I guess washing hands removes the body naturally produced oil and that makes it harder to scan.