Per @[email protected]’s suggestion in the thread announcing the closure of the tank comms I am suggesting a replacement comm
The concept of the comm is that it would be exactly the same as the_dunk_tank but without the unfortunate racist connotations of the name. Also, the name actually describes the content that is intended for it. Not sure why we made it any more complicated than that in the first place. Also, you can post things like articles from The Atlantic, which are also notable, and not just stuff about famous people.
Also, we should just go ahead and unlock Dredge_Tank
Locking these comms was a mistake, and trying to ban “low effort” posts will kill the site long term. We’re a shitposting social media site descended from a shitposting subreddit. Shitposting is part of our culture–a big part. If you ban low-effort posts, you’re not going to get more effort posts–you’re just going to get fewer posts. A lot of people come here in part because they can post some essay or take by an esteemed Elder Statesman or Media Thinker and say “look at this dumb shit.” Not only is that important to site culture and participation itself, lots of deeper engagement comes along with that activity.
Reopen dredge, and change the name of the other one.
The wording of the announcement has been changed several times. I don’t think it specifically mentions low effort posting now but it wasn’t very clear before it was edited and it isn’t very clear now.
There hasn’t been any real explanation of what the problem was that merited this change. Afaik only one Dunk tank mod commented on the reasoning and their comment was patronizing, unhelpful, and suggested more of a disconnect between the mod team and the users than an actual problem.
If that’s not the reason, then I’m totally puzzled by what the argument even is. I’m all for changing the name, but if we’re not worried about post quality, why exactly are we closing the comms?