Posting this because no one else seems to want to, and it’s a discussion worth having outside of drama or personal conflicts. I’m undecided and can see both sides, but it’s important to address.

Potential benefits of a limit:

  • Frequent posters hold significant influence and could, in theory, push misinformation or propaganda (though I haven’t seen evidence of this it’s a fair concern).
  • A community dominated by one or two voices might discourage new members from participating.
  • Encouraging quality over quantity could increase the value of individual posts.

Potential downsides of a limit:

  • Could reduce overall community engagement.
  • If set too low, it might discourage meaningful participation from well-intentioned members.
  • It could inadvertently encourage the (mis)use of alt accounts.

These are some pros/cons but certainly not all! I encourage more discussion below.

  • PhilipTheBucket@ponder.cat
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    8 hours ago

    I actually meant a different user, not UniversalMonk. This whole meta post stemmed out of some minor unrelated localized drama, I didn’t name the user because it’s 100% irrelevant to this whole discussion except in the sense of having sparked it off in the first place.

    But also, UniveralMonk posted a lot more than 3 times. For anyone who’s an admin, the query if you’re interested is:

    Huge SQL Query
    WITH daily_post_counts AS (
      SELECT 
        DATE(p.published) as post_date,
        p.creator_id,
        per.actor_id as poster_actor_id,
        COUNT(*) as post_count,
        -- Rank posters within each day by their post count
        ROW_NUMBER() OVER (
          PARTITION BY DATE(p.published) 
          ORDER BY COUNT(*) DESC
        ) as poster_rank
      FROM post p
      JOIN person per ON p.creator_id = per.id
      WHERE 
        -- Filter for the specific community
        p.community_id = (
          SELECT id 
          FROM community 
          WHERE actor_id = 'https://lemmy.world/c/politics'
        )
        -- Exclude deleted and removed posts
        AND NOT p.deleted 
        AND NOT p.removed
      GROUP BY 
        DATE(p.published),
        p.creator_id,
        per.actor_id
    )
    SELECT 
      post_date,
      poster_actor_id,
      post_count
    FROM daily_post_counts
    WHERE poster_rank <= 3
    ORDER BY 
      post_date DESC,
      post_count DESC;
    

    It’s actually a lot more interesting to look over than I thought it would be. It’s all pretty normal at the beginning, but then at the end of April, there starts to be a sprinkling of a multitude of pretty-bad-faith-IMO posters, all starting to be represented more or less at the same time. They all just kind of start up in a little sprinkling, and then at the beginning of July, that stops and it starts to be almost all either normal posters or return2ozma, and then in early August UniversalMonk shows up, and they’re both heavily featured from then on. They’re both competitive with the heaviest of the other posters, with UniversalMonk peaking I think at 17 posts in one day on October 8th. Then, in late October, UM gets banned, and it goes back completely to normal except for occasional bursts of single posters ([email protected] being an example) popping up and doing super-heavy posting and then disppearing as they get banned.

    I also see at least one of the heavy productive-post posters, that people don’t tend to hate the posts of, dropping out of the rotation, when they used to be heavily featured. That to me is a really sad thing. I have no idea why, sometimes stuff happens, but to me it seems at least a little bit likely that they got driven away by the periodic floods of propaganda and nonsense infesting what was just a normal news community, which would be really sad if that’s how it happened.

    • Donald J. Musk@lemmy.today
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      7
      ·
      edit-2
      4 hours ago

      Let’s talk about stats.

      You make, on average over the last 7 months: 13 comments per day.

      And you post, on average over the last 7 months: 6 posts per day.

      More the Universal Monk. So about trolls/spamming, what do you have to say about your own numbers?

    • Donald J. Musk@lemmy.today
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      6 hours ago

      UniversalMonk peaking I think at 17 posts in one day on October 8th

      In one community though? Because that’s like 2 posts a day over an 8 hour day. Lots of posters post more than that even now, and they’re not called trolls. Look at how much Blaze posts and comments. lol

      And you, yourself sir, are on A LOT. Like how many posts and comments do you make a day?