no lol, she deserved what she got just like every unrepentant royal does
the closest to sympathy i get for royals is feeling bad that the romanov children had to be executed, but that was a matter of pragmatism rather than justice
perhaps, but it was an ongoing civil war where leaving one of them alive could have led to them being captured by the Whites which would have been a huge boon and rallying point for the disunited White movement. with Puyi it was different because the right KMT were republicans too and would have probably executed Puyi, especially since he had been a collaborator of the highest order with the Japanese. if he’d been captured by the enemy then it wouldn’t have been potentially disastrous for the CPC in the way that capture of a Romanov by the Whites would have been for the Bolsheviks
Henry Puyi was one of the weakest leaders of the 20th century. He had no will of his own and went whichever way the wind blew. He was such a loser he couldn’t even get a girlfriend. They took him to a girls’ high school where he picked one of the girls to be empress. He ended up not only serving the Japanese, but ended up sweeping the streets (the lowest possible occupation) after China’s revolution. He didn’t even have the sense to escape to a comfortable retirement like any tyrant.
The last emperor of China lived out a decade as a civilian under Chinese Communist rule. It is very possible that the Romanov children could have enjoyed the same fate. Either way, it isn’t as though the western powers were shy about funneling money and weapons to the White Army during the 1920s or the German Nationalists during the 1930s or various anti-Communist European factions indefinitely.
Hell, Americans were chomping at the bit to embrace a legion of Anastasia imposters well into the 1990s when FOX Animation Studio decided to climb aboard the revisionist train and plant its own knife in the back of the USSR.
Killing the Romanov kids did exactly dick-all to help the Soviet movement.
I mean, they had the French Revolution. And executing Antoinette was a big part of what brought the Austrians in as counter-revolutionaries so aggressively.
no lol, she deserved what she got just like every unrepentant royal does
the closest to sympathy i get for royals is feeling bad that the romanov children had to be executed, but that was a matter of pragmatism rather than justice
Yeah maybe the Romanov children could have just kept alive like that dude from China son of the Emperor.
perhaps, but it was an ongoing civil war where leaving one of them alive could have led to them being captured by the Whites which would have been a huge boon and rallying point for the disunited White movement. with Puyi it was different because the right KMT were republicans too and would have probably executed Puyi, especially since he had been a collaborator of the highest order with the Japanese. if he’d been captured by the enemy then it wouldn’t have been potentially disastrous for the CPC in the way that capture of a Romanov by the Whites would have been for the Bolsheviks
eh, yeah. But the little shits were small, maybe they could have hide them in a wardrobe or something.
And they would always have been a problem. Unfortunately for them, when the benefits of being royalty run out, life sucks.
that is the risk you take when you run the country as a tyrannical hereditary monarchy. Your whole family becomes a problem.
Henry Puyi was one of the weakest leaders of the 20th century. He had no will of his own and went whichever way the wind blew. He was such a loser he couldn’t even get a girlfriend. They took him to a girls’ high school where he picked one of the girls to be empress. He ended up not only serving the Japanese, but ended up sweeping the streets (the lowest possible occupation) after China’s revolution. He didn’t even have the sense to escape to a comfortable retirement like any tyrant.
The little I’ve read about him suggests that he genuinely repented and was quite happy to live the life of an ordinary citizens.
No. They could not be. What happened was best.
Had they been left alive the civil war could’ve drawn on longer with further intervention from the west.
The last emperor of China lived out a decade as a civilian under Chinese Communist rule. It is very possible that the Romanov children could have enjoyed the same fate. Either way, it isn’t as though the western powers were shy about funneling money and weapons to the White Army during the 1920s or the German Nationalists during the 1930s or various anti-Communist European factions indefinitely.
Hell, Americans were chomping at the bit to embrace a legion of Anastasia imposters well into the 1990s when FOX Animation Studio decided to climb aboard the revisionist train and plant its own knife in the back of the USSR.
Killing the Romanov kids did exactly dick-all to help the Soviet movement.
you have the benefit of hindsight which the bolsheviks did not have. in their situation of course they did what they did.
I mean, they had the French Revolution. And executing Antoinette was a big part of what brought the Austrians in as counter-revolutionaries so aggressively.
did you not read the meme in this post?
Yes. Its ahistorical.
sure. the monarchist powers of europe would totally have left revolutionary france alone if they had just let the leeches keep their heads. totally.