• 2 Posts
  • 25 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 26th, 2023

help-circle









  • I believe M’Benga that it was self defense. If you think about how Dak’Rah was goading him it was obvious that he wanted to suss out what our good doctor knew about what happened in J’Gal. Remember, as M’Benga was killing his 2nd, 3rd, and 4th in command he was fleeing and knew there was someone out there who knows the truth of what happened. Given the large number of casualties, he most likely is on high alert when he comes across anyone who “was there”. He figures Ortegas and Chapel don’t have it in them to assassinate 3 Klingons so that leaves M’Benga who (upon rewatch) has this dark edgy energy, so… maybe? When he finally gets the truth out of M’Benga he has no choice but to kill the person who can disrupt his new cushy life.

    Thinking about it, either M’Benga dies or he dies. Let’s say M’Benga spares his life and exposes him for the coward that he is. He tried to kill civilians! His own people too! The Federation could never allow him to continue his cushy life and his fellow Klingons would never allow him to live after finding out. To not make that attempt to kill M’Benga first would be an illogical choice.

    Also other questions to consider:

    Did M’Benga hold back during the sparring so as not to give away his abilities?

    How threatening was Rah? What if Rah had just said something like “I’m going to make sure no one knows the real story” and M’Benga takes that to mean Rah will kill him at the first justifiable opportunity? So might as well defend himself now?

    M’Benga would have to know exactly where to stab so that the 2nd Klingon heart doesn’t keep him alive. Otherwise what are the chances of hitting that right spot by luck?








  • Would Pike have pulled the trigger if it not for the happy coincidence of gaining his memory back? (Doylist explanation being that the writers can’t just have our highly esteemed captain straight up murder a guy). High Lord Zacarias begging for his life like a little pissant sure thought he was capable of it. Was Quark right? Starve humans of their desires long enough and they will be worse than the Klingons and Cardassians. It didn’t take Pike very long to go fucking nuts!

    Even Pike seems shaken at what his stance was when he came out of his amnesia.

    Alternately, another interpretation of that scene I had is that when Humans do remember that they are supposed to be kind forgiving people, there is indeed a chance for redemption and it was kind of a nice juxtapose that the Zac knew he didn’t have to goad Pike into pulling the trigger. Even when he’s dejected and says that he’s done a lot against his duties and the law, he was ready to face the consequences than cowardly escape them with death. Klingons want to “die with honour” but it seems like humans prefer to live with honour.





  • I don’t think you can go wrong with either one! I love TNG and rewatch it constantly. You’re right that TOS has fewer takers but I’m sure there will be some who will want to re-watch to refresh their memories on the details of the episodes. My partner and I rewatched Balance of Terror, the Cage, Arena, and Space Seed because of SNW. I’m sure others wouldn’t be here if we weren’t down to discuss any Trek in some way.