we are going to have a lovely discussion about this video >:3
i ain’t watching all that. happy for you tho. or sorry that happened
Clearly for Jimmy Dore, once a news outlet has been caught lying they can never be trustworthy again, which certainly has a lot of populist appeal as an idea [31:31]
…but… isn’t that accurate tho?? :cat-confused:
Yeah, not taking this bait. Her argumentation style makes me crazy. I’ve stopped watching a bunch of Thoughtslime’s stuff because of her. I love my anarchist comrades, but there is a specific, irritating subset of anarchists who cannot examine their own priors. Of course, the same could be said for communists (See Caleb Maupin, whose sole redeeming trait is a higher-than-average chance to come up with good names for terrible things), so it isn’t anarchist-specific or anything.
I stopped watching at 28:38 when she frames Jimmy Dore as a crank for believing that the Syrian gas attacks were false flags.
I mean, Jimmy Dore is a crank on vaccines, horse paste, and probably several other things, but he’s right about the OPCW leaks.
Edit: Decided to continue watching anyway (even though I disagree) because her video is thought provoking.
Edit2: I got to her full explanation of the events [43:05] and it’s much worse than I expected. Her argument is “AKSHYUALLY the gas attacks weren’t PROVEN to be false flags, they were just proven to not have taken place in the way we were first told, and Jimmy Dore is a crank for believing that indicates it’s a false flag because he’s just emotionally motivated by his anti-imperialist views”.
Okay, but I’d argue that the false flag explanation is the next most coherent one since the official story has been debunked, and that you’re emotionally motivated by your disdain for anti-imperialists and “dictators who commit horrific crimes”.
Then she thinks she’s making a big-brained point when she says that the media could be telling the truth about the gas attacks while still be guilty of cynically exploiting them for their purposes.
Straight up, the Syria point was why I wanted to post it here. Having milquetoast Ukraine takes is fine, but this was something that made me raise my eyebrows
Hearing communists criticize Chomsky for the first time made me go into defensive mode like this as well. Glad I didn’t have a giant platform or I would have made cringe like this too.
