Bar graph of absolute percentages before & after overlaid. For example, a darker outline rectangle for 2023 and a lighter filled rectangle for 2024. Or just two rectangles next to each other, as lots of business charts do.
So it would still be a bar graph. I thought your argument was that it wasn’t the right type of graph for this dataset, not that you disagreed with the dataset used in the first place. I agree that the one you proposed is easier to understood, but I don’t really agree that using it like they did is improper. It is certainly useful if you want to save space.
What graph works better to show relative percentage change?
Bar graph of absolute percentages before & after overlaid. For example, a darker outline rectangle for 2023 and a lighter filled rectangle for 2024. Or just two rectangles next to each other, as lots of business charts do.
So it would still be a bar graph. I thought your argument was that it wasn’t the right type of graph for this dataset, not that you disagreed with the dataset used in the first place. I agree that the one you proposed is easier to understood, but I don’t really agree that using it like they did is improper. It is certainly useful if you want to save space.